
By HistorianSpeaks
When Justice Devindra Rampersad of the Trinidad and Tobago High Court ruled in April 2018 that the country's "buggery" and "serious indecency" laws were unconstitutional, people danced outside the Hall of Justice in Port of Spain. Seven years later, the Court of Appeal restored the laws in a split decision. On November 6, 2026, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council reversed the appeals court and settled the matter. Jason Jones, the activist who brought the case, had won.
The Jones ruling is the latest in a decade-long wave of Caribbean cases that have dismantled colonial penal laws island by island. This second part of the HistorianSpeaks series traces that wave, the trans people who fought some of its hardest battles and the four countries where the old laws still stand.
Laws Written for an Empire
British colonial authorities brought the Offences Against the Person Act of 1861 and its relatives to the Caribbean. After independence, many countries kept the language and in some cases made the penalties harsher. Trinidad and Tobago's 1986 Sexual Offences Act set a maximum sentence of 25 years for "buggery." Barbados's law carried a possible life sentence. Jamaica's 1864 statute, still in force, allows up to ten years at hard labor.
A second obstacle was built into the independence constitutions themselves. Many contain "savings clauses," which shield laws that existed before independence from constitutional challenge. For years, governments argued that these clauses made the colonial sex laws untouchable. Much of the recent litigation has turned on whether judges can read around those clauses or whether laws later reenacted by local parliaments lose that protection.


Belize Breaks the Wall
The first crack came in Belize. Caleb Orozco, a leader of the United Belize Advocacy Movement (UNIBAM), challenged Section 53 of the criminal code, which punished "carnal intercourse against the order of nature" with up to ten years in prison. Orozco received death threats and was physically attacked during the case. In August 2016, Chief Justice Kenneth Benjamin ruled that the law violated Orozco's rights to dignity, privacy and equality. Belize's Court of Appeal largely upheld the decision in 2019.
Orozco's victory showed that a Caribbean judge, applying a Caribbean constitution, could strike down a colonial law. It became the model for the cases that followed. It also demonstrated a cost that later claimants would share. Litigants in small island societies cannot easily disappear into a crowd. Their names, faces and families become public, and some, like Orozco, live for years with security concerns. Every case on the list below exists because someone accepted that risk.

Trans Women at the Front
The most direct challenge to colonial policing of gender came from Guyana. In February 2009, police in Georgetown arrested several trans women and charged them under a section of the Summary Jurisdiction (Offences) Act that made it a crime for a man to wear "female attire" in public for an "improper purpose." The presiding magistrate reportedly told the defendants they were confused about their gender and should give their lives to Jesus Christ.
Four of the women, led by Quincy McEwan and supported by the Society Against Sexual Orientation Discrimination (SASOD), took the case all the way to the Caribbean Court of Justice, Guyana's final court. In November 2018, the CCJ struck down the law in McEwan v. Attorney General of Guyana. The court found it unconstitutionally vague and discriminatory and said the magistrate's remarks had no place in a courtroom. It was the first time the region's highest court ruled on trans rights.
Elsewhere in the region, trans activists built the support networks that made litigation possible. In Barbados, trans activist Alexa Hoffmann helped lead advocacy around the 2022 challenge and testified publicly about the harassment she faced. In Jamaica, TransWave Jamaica, founded in 2015, has worked on health care and legal recognition. The region still carries painful reminders of the stakes. In July 2013, 16-year-old Dwayne Jones, a gender-nonconforming teenager, was beaten and killed by a mob after attending a party in Montego Bay in a dress.
The Cascade
After Belize, the cases came quickly. In July 2022, the High Court of Antigua and Barbuda struck down that country's law in a case brought by Orden David and the Women Against Rape organization. In August 2022, St. Kitts and Nevis followed in a case brought by Jamal Jeffers. In December 2022, Barbados's High Court ruled in favor of plaintiffs including René Holder-McClean-Ramirez. Dominica's High Court ruled in April 2024, and Saint Lucia's courts followed. Now, Trinidad and Tobago joins them.
Several of these cases were coordinated through the Eastern Caribbean Alliance for Diversity and Equality (ECADE), with legal help from the Human Dignity Trust. That partnership matters. Critics like to call these cases foreign interference, but the claimants were local residents arguing from their own constitutions, and the judges were Caribbean jurists.
Factbook: The Caribbean Wave
Belize (2016): Orozco v. Attorney General; Section 53 struck down.
Guyana (2018): McEwan at the CCJ; cross-dressing law struck down. Same-sex intimacy law remains.
Antigua and Barbuda (July 2022), St. Kitts and Nevis (August 2022), Barbados (December 2022): High Court rulings decriminalize.
Dominica (2024) and Saint Lucia: Courts strike down colonial laws.
Trinidad and Tobago (November 6, 2026): Privy Council restores 2018 High Court ruling in Jones.
Still criminalizing: Jamaica, St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Grenada, Guyana.
The Four Holdouts
Jamaica is the largest and most closely watched. In 2021, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights found that Jamaica's laws violated the rights of two Jamaicans, Gareth Henry and Simone Edwards, who had fled the country after violent attacks, and urged repeal. The government has not complied. A domestic challenge by Maurice Tomlinson, a Jamaican lawyer and activist, has moved slowly through the courts.
St. Vincent and the Grenadines handed down a setback in 2024, when its High Court rejected a challenge brought by Javin Johnson and Sean MacLeish. An appeal is pending. Grenada faces a challenge filed with ECADE's support. Guyana, despite McEwan, still criminalizes same-sex intimacy between men, and SASOD and Guyana Trans United continue to press for repeal.
In each of these countries, religious organizations have opposed decriminalization, sometimes with support from U.S.-based groups. But public opinion is shifting, especially among young people, and every new ruling from a neighbor makes the old laws harder to defend.
Who Decides?
The Jones ruling raises a sensitive question. Trinidad and Tobago is one of several Caribbean states that still send final appeals to the Privy Council in London rather than to the Caribbean Court of Justice. Some politicians will say that British judges imposed this outcome. The truth is more complicated. The Privy Council relied on Caribbean precedents, especially Belize and Barbados, and adopted the reasoning of a Trinidadian judge. Supporters of the CCJ, meanwhile, can point to McEwan as proof that a Caribbean court can protect minorities on its own.
Either way, the direction is set. A legal regime built by an empire to police Caribbean bodies is being taken apart by Caribbean people. In the words of the Privy Council, "the trend is clear."
---
Sources & Verification
Case dates and holdings were checked against court records, the Human Dignity Trust legal database and contemporaneous reporting. The status of the remaining holdouts reflects the Human Dignity Trust's November 6, 2026, statement.
Why your support matters
Follow the global Black story. One dispatch a week, free.
HistorianSpeaks is independent and reader-supported. No corporate owners, no paywall on the daily history. Every member keeps stories like this one coming.
Free
Newsletter
The weekly dispatch in your inbox.
Founding member
$9.99/month
Price locked for life, founder recognition and full Black Thread magazine access.
Become a founderAsk the Historian
Have a question about this story, or an idea for a future post? Send it here.
