HistorianSpeaks emblemHistorianSpeaks

Before the Law, Beyond the Binary: Colonial Codes, State Backlash and the Trans-Led Fight for Dignity

7 min read · 1,717 words
Trans rights activists Min Matson and Janetta Johnson at a Transgender Day of Remembrance panel, San Francisco, 2016. Photo: Pax Ahimsa Gethen, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Trans rights activists Min Matson and Janetta Johnson at a Transgender Day of Remembrance panel, San Francisco, 2016. Photo: Pax Ahimsa Gethen, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

By HistorianSpeaks

On November 6, 2026, five judges of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London ruled that Trinidad and Tobago could no longer jail people for loving each other. The case, Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v. Jason Jones, ended a fight that Jones, a Trinidadian activist, began nearly a decade earlier. The court struck down the "buggery" and "serious indecency" sections of the country's 1986 Sexual Offences Act and observed, after reviewing a string of similar Caribbean rulings, that "the trend is clear."

The ruling arrives two weeks before Transgender Day of Remembrance on November 20, the day communities around the world read aloud the names of trans people killed in the past year. The timing is a reminder that court victories and funerals are part of the same story. This essay opens a five-part HistorianSpeaks series on the criminalization of LGBTQ+ people, and on the movements dismantling those laws, across the Caribbean, Africa, the United States and Canada. Each part centers trans people, who have been the first targets of state policing and, again and again, the first to fight back.

An Empire's Boilerplate

The laws now falling across the Commonwealth were not written in Port of Spain, Kampala or Kingston. They were drafted in Britain and exported as standard equipment of colonial rule. England's Buggery Act of 1533 became, in the nineteenth century, the template for imperial penal codes. Thomas Babington Macaulay's Indian Penal Code of 1860, with its Section 377 against "carnal intercourse against the order of nature," was copied into colonies from Singapore to East Africa. In the Caribbean, the Offences Against the Person Act of 1861 served the same purpose; Jamaica's 1864 version is still on its books.

According to the Human Dignity Trust, which tracks these statutes, most of the countries that still criminalize same-sex intimacy today are former British colonies. That fact upends a common political claim. Leaders in Uganda, Ghana and parts of the Caribbean often describe LGBTQ+ identity as a "Western import." The historical record shows the reverse. The import was the criminal law. Scholars such as Ifi Amadiume, Stephen O. Murray and Marc Epprecht have documented gender and sexual diversity in many African societies long before colonial rule, from Igbo "female husbands" to gender-crossing spiritual roles. Colonial administrators and missionaries treated those traditions as savagery and wrote punishment into law.

Trans rights activists Min Matson and Janetta Johnson speak at a Transgender Day of Remembrance panel in San Francisco, November 2016. Johnson, a Black trans woman, leads the TGI Justice Project. Photo: Pax Ahimsa Gethen, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Trans rights activists Min Matson and Janetta Johnson speak at a Transgender Day of Remembrance panel in San Francisco, November 2016. Johnson, a Black trans woman, leads the TGI Justice Project. Photo: Pax Ahimsa Gethen, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Why Trans People Were Policed First

The sodomy statutes targeted acts. A second set of colonial laws targeted appearance. Vagrancy, "rogue and vagabond" and cross-dressing ordinances allowed police to arrest people simply for how they looked on the street. In Guyana, a provision of the Summary Jurisdiction (Offences) Act made it a crime for a man to appear in public "in female attire" for an "improper purpose." Similar rules existed in U.S. cities, where "masquerade" laws were used against gender-nonconforming people well into the twentieth century.

These laws fell hardest on trans women of color, who were most visible, most often poor and least protected. That is why trans people stood at the front of so many of the fights that followed. In 2018, the Caribbean Court of Justice struck down Guyana's cross-dressing law in McEwan v. Attorney General of Guyana, a case brought by trans women who had been arrested and mocked by a magistrate. In New York in 1969, Marsha P. Johnson and Sylvia Rivera were among the people who resisted police at the Stonewall Inn. In Botswana in 2017, a trans man known in court papers as ND won the right to have his gender recognized.

Four Regions, One Pattern

The Caribbean. Since Caleb Orozco won his case in Belize in 2016, courts have struck down colonial laws in Trinidad and Tobago, Antigua and Barbuda, St. Kitts and Nevis, Barbados, Dominica and Saint Lucia. According to the Human Dignity Trust, only Jamaica, St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Grenada and Guyana still criminalize same-sex intimacy in the English-speaking Caribbean, and those laws face challenges.

Africa. The picture is mixed. South Africa's 1996 constitution was the first in the world to bar discrimination based on sexual orientation. Botswana, Mozambique, Angola, Mauritius, Seychelles and Namibia have decriminalized through courts or new penal codes. At the same time, Uganda's Anti-Homosexuality Act of 2023 allows the death penalty for "aggravated homosexuality," and Ghana's parliament has pushed its own harsh bill. Investigations by openDemocracy and others have traced money and messaging behind some of these campaigns to U.S.-based Christian right organizations.

The United States. The Supreme Court ended sodomy laws in Lawrence v. Texas in 2003, and in Bostock v. Clayton County in 2020 it ruled that firing someone for being gay or transgender is sex discrimination. Yet the country is now in the middle of the most intense legislative campaign against trans people in its history, with more than half the states restricting gender-affirming care for minors. In June 2025 the Supreme Court upheld Tennessee's ban in United States v. Skrmetti. Black trans women remain the people most often named on Transgender Day of Remembrance lists in the United States.

Canada. Parliament partially decriminalized homosexuality in 1969, added gender identity and expression to federal human rights law in 2017 and banned conversion therapy in 2021. Indigenous communities have also revived the term Two-Spirit, adopted at a 1990 gathering in Winnipeg, to reclaim gender roles that residential schools and missionaries tried to erase. Even so, several provinces have adopted school policies that require parental consent for students to change their names or pronouns, and Saskatchewan used the constitution's notwithstanding clause to shield its law from court challenges.

Factbook: The Legal Map in 2026

Colonial roots: Most laws criminalizing same-sex intimacy worldwide trace to British colonial codes, including the Offences Against the Person Act of 1861 and the Indian Penal Code of 1860.

Caribbean holdouts: Jamaica, St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Grenada and Guyana (Human Dignity Trust, November 2026).

African decriminalizers: South Africa (1998), Mozambique (2015), Seychelles (2016), Botswana (2019, upheld 2021), Angola (2021), Mauritius (2023), Namibia (2024).

United States: Sodomy laws void since 2003; Skrmetti (2025) upheld state limits on gender-affirming care for minors.

Canada: Gender identity protected federally since 2017 (Bill C-16); conversion therapy banned since 2022 (Bill C-4).

The Movements That Refused to Leave

What ties these regions together is not only shared law. It is shared determination. The people who won these cases usually stayed in their countries and fought there. Orozco faced threats in Belize. Jason Jones, who lived for years in Britain, returned home and filed suit in his own name. In Botswana, the group LEGABIBO spent years in court just to win the right to register as an organization before it helped win decriminalization. In Uganda, Frank Mugisha and Sexual Minorities Uganda keep working under a law that could imprison them. In the United States, groups such as the Transgender Law Center and the Marsha P. Johnson Institute carry Johnson's name and mission forward.

These activists do not frame their cause as a gift from London, Washington or Ottawa. They argue from their own constitutions and their own histories. The Privy Council, a relic of empire, may have issued the final word in Jones, but the arguments it accepted came from Caribbean judges and Caribbean litigants. As Téa Braun of the Human Dignity Trust said after the ruling, the decision affirms "the inherent dignity of LGBT+ people living in Trinidad and Tobago." That dignity was always theirs. The law is only now catching up.

What Comes Next in This Series

The four parts that follow go deeper. Part Two traces the Caribbean decriminalization wave and its trans litigants. Part Three examines Africa, from precolonial gender diversity to today's legislative battles. Part Four looks at the U.S. statehouse campaign and the Black trans women at its center. Part Five turns to Canada and the Two-Spirit movement. A future installment will turn to Central and South America, where civil law traditions and the Inter-American Court have produced a different path.

On November 20, as names are read aloud, it is worth remembering both halves of this history: the laws that made trans and queer people criminals, and the people who refused to accept it.

---

Sources & Verification

Facts in this piece were checked against court records, the Human Dignity Trust's legal database and the reporting listed below. The Trinidad and Tobago ruling and the list of remaining Caribbean holdouts come from the Human Dignity Trust's November 6, 2026, statement.

Why your support matters

Follow the global Black story. One dispatch a week, free.

HistorianSpeaks is independent and reader-supported. No corporate owners, no paywall on the daily history. Every member keeps stories like this one coming.

Free

Newsletter

The weekly dispatch in your inbox.

Most impact

Founding member

$9.99/month

Price locked for life, founder recognition and full Black Thread magazine access.

Become a founder

Student

$4.99/month

Every Black Thread story in full, with a school (.edu) email.

Join as a student
Share:
Cite this blog:
"Before the Law, Beyond the Binary: Colonial Codes, State Backlash and the Trans-Led Fight for Dignity." Historianspeaks, November 16, 2026. https://historianspeaks.org/blog/before-the-law-beyond-the-binary.

Ask the Historian

Have a question about this story, or an idea for a future post? Send it here.

Stay Current

Join our mailing list

One dispatch a week: a new essay, a podcast episode, and something from the archive worth a second look.