
Part two of our Haiti series — the backstory to "One History, One Struggle" in the debut issue of [Black Thread](/magazine), November 1.
On the morning of February 7, 1986, a U.S. Air Force cargo plane lifted off from Port-au-Prince carrying Jean-Claude Duvalier, his wife Michèle Bennett and a fortune taken from one of the poorest nations in the hemisphere. Haitians poured into the streets. They tore down statues, smashed the tomb of his father, François, and began a word that would define the next decade: dechoukaj, "uprooting." Twenty-nine years of family dictatorship were over. What came next would test whether a people who had made the first free Black republic could reclaim it from their own rulers and from Washington.
A Dynasty Built on Fear
François "Papa Doc" Duvalier, a physician who had fought typhus and yaws in the countryside, won the presidency in 1957 by casting himself as the champion of the Black majority against a lighter-skinned elite. He promoted Black officers, drew on Vodou to claim spiritual authority, and named himself president for life in 1964. His private militia, the Tonton Macoutes, terrorized critics, and tens of thousands of Haitians were killed or driven into exile. Doctors, teachers and lawyers fled to New York, Montreal and Africa, a brain drain Haiti still feels.


When Papa Doc died in 1971, power passed to his 19-year-old son. "Baby Doc" promised economic modernization and courted American assembly plants, but graft deepened. His 1980 marriage to Michèle Bennett, whose family was tied to drug trafficking and other scandals, angered even the elite. In 1983 Pope John Paul II told Haitians that "things must change here." By 1985 protests had spread from Gonaïves to Les Cayes and Cap-Haïtien, and the Reagan administration, its patience gone, arranged his exit to France.

Duvalierism Without Duvalier
The uprooting did not reach the army. A military council under General Henri Namphy took charge, and old Macoutes changed uniforms rather than leave. Haitians wrote a new constitution in 1987 and ratified it by a wide margin, but when they went to vote that November, gunmen massacred voters at a Port-au-Prince school and the election was canceled. A 1988 vote installed the civilian Leslie Manigat for barely four months before Namphy removed him; General Prosper Avril then removed Namphy. Between 1986 and 1990 Haiti went through a carousel of generals while the poor kept pressing in the streets.
The Priest of the Slums

The voice of that pressure belonged to Jean-Bertrand Aristide, a Salesian priest at the church of Saint-Jean Bosco in La Saline, one of the capital's poorest neighborhoods. Followers called him Titid. His sermons joined liberation theology to the language of the Haitian Revolution, and his movement, Lavalas, "the flood," promised to wash away the old order. Gunmen attacked his church during Mass in September 1988, killing worshipers and burning the building. His order expelled him for politics. He kept preaching.
On December 16, 1990, in the first free presidential election in Haitian history, Aristide won about 67 percent of the vote. A coup attempt by Duvalierist Roger Lafontant before the inauguration was crushed by crowds in the streets. Aristide took office on February 7, 1991, five years to the day after Baby Doc's flight.
Seven Months, Then the Coup
His government moved against corruption, drug trafficking and army privilege and pushed for a higher minimum wage, which alarmed business elites and officers alike. On September 30, 1991, the army under General Raoul Cédras overthrew him. Aristide went into exile, first to Venezuela and then Washington. Over the next three years the military and the paramilitary group FRAPH killed thousands of Lavalas supporters. Tens of thousands of Haitians took to the sea.
The United States answered with a policy that turned refugees back. Coast Guard cutters intercepted boats and returned people to the regime they fled, under President George H. W. Bush's 1992 Kennebunkport Order, upheld by the Supreme Court in Sale v. Haitian Centers Council (1993) and kept by President Bill Clinton, who had criticized it as a candidate. For Black Americans the double standard was plain: Cubans fleeing communism were welcomed, while Black Haitians fleeing a military that had killed their elected president were sent home.
Randall Robinson's Hunger Strike

Randall Robinson, founder of TransAfrica, had already helped lead the Free South Africa Movement and the fight for the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act of 1986. On April 11, 1994, he stopped eating. He drank only water and juice and grew weaker in public view, while members of the Congressional Black Caucus pressed the White House and some were arrested in protest outside it.
"The army there, together with paramilitary thugs called FRAPH, has murdered upwards of five thousand civilians—men, women, children," he wrote on the nineteenth day. Fifty thousand people, he noted, had fled "onto the vast and capricious sea in overcrowded, rickety boats." They fled anyway, "because the odds at sea are better than staying home."
On May 8, after 27 days, the Clinton administration changed course and agreed to give Haitian boat people hearings rather than return them automatically. Robinson ended his fast. The policy shift helped push Washington toward Aristide's return.

The Return
With a United Nations mandate behind it, the United States prepared to invade. A last-minute delegation of Jimmy Carter, Colin Powell and Senator Sam Nunn persuaded Cédras to step down as planes were already in the air, and on September 19, 1994, some 20,000 American troops landed unopposed. On October 15, Aristide flew home to finish his term. He disbanded the army in 1995 and handed power to René Préval in 1996, Haiti's first peaceful transfer between elected presidents.
The return came with conditions, including economic programs written in Washington, and the gains proved fragile. That story continues in A Nation Under Siege: Haiti After Aristide, 2004–2026. Haitians had shown again what they had shown in 1804: they could uproot tyranny themselves. Black Americans like Robinson had shown that the diaspora could make Washington listen.

Where the Full Story Lives
This piece is part of our free Haiti series: Remember the River, then From Baby Doc to Titid, then A Nation Under Siege. Together they are the backstory. The full story, One History, One Struggle: What Da'Vinchi's Comments Can Teach Us About Haiti and Black America, appears in the debut issue of Black Thread, our monthly magazine. It traces two centuries of ties between Haiti and Black America. Magazine features are for members at $9.99/month, and our blogs and archive stay free. Join here.
Why your support matters
Liked this story? Get one like it in your inbox every week.
HistorianSpeaks is independent and reader-supported. No corporate owners, no paywall on the daily history. Every member keeps stories like this one coming.
Free
Newsletter
The weekly dispatch in your inbox.
Founding member
$9.99/month
Price locked for life, founder recognition and full Black Thread magazine access.
Become a founderAsk the Historian
Have a question about this story, or an idea for a future post? Send it here.
