Denial at the Door: Juliette Derricotte and the Deadly Logic of Segregated Hospitals

A Leader on the Road

Juliette Derricotte was one of the most respected young Black women in America. A graduate of Talladega College, she had worked for the national YWCA's student movement and traveled abroad as a delegate to the World Student Christian Federation. In 1929 she became dean of women at Fisk University in Nashville. She was 34 years old when segregation killed her.

Dalton, Georgia, November 1931

On November 6, 1931, Derricotte was driving three Fisk students to Georgia when a white driver swerved and struck her car, overturning it into a ditch. He shouted at the injured passengers for damaging his car and drove away without helping.

The closest hospital, Hamilton Memorial in Dalton, did not admit Black patients. White doctors treated Derricotte and the students in their private offices, and then the two most seriously injured, Derricotte and student Nina Johnson, were left to recover in the home of a local Black woman. Six hours after the crash, the others arranged to take them to a hospital in Chattanooga, 35 miles away. Johnson died on the way. Derricotte died the next day, November 7.

The Investigation

The Commission on Interracial Cooperation investigated, and in December 1931 NAACP secretary Walter White traveled south to learn what happened. His conclusion was blunt: "The barbarity of race segregation in the South is shown in all its brutal ugliness by the willingness to let cultured, respected, and leading colored women die for lack of hospital facilities." Black newspapers across the country carried the story, and for many readers it confirmed what they already knew: no degree, title or reputation protected a Black person at the hospital door.

Medicine as a Color Line

Derricotte's death was part of a system. Across the South, hospitals refused Black patients or confined them to crowded basement wards. Black physicians were barred from staff positions, and Black communities built their own hospitals and nursing schools in response. The federal Hill-Burton Act of 1946 funded hospital construction while permitting "separate but equal" facilities, until the 1963 Simkins v. Moses H. Cone Memorial Hospital decision and the 1964 Civil Rights Act opened the way to desegregation. Medicare's 1966 requirement that hospitals integrate to receive federal money finally forced change at scale.

The gaps in care that followed did not vanish with the law. Today's disparities in Black maternal deaths and hospital closures in Black and rural communities carry the same question Derricotte's death raised: who is turned away, and who decides.

HistorianSpeaks is reader-supported. [Join free or become a founding member for $9.99/month](/join) to keep this history in front of the public.