HistorianSpeaks emblemHistorianSpeaks

What GTA Gets Wrong About Black Men

13 min read · 3,095 words
Photo: PattayaPatrol / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Photo: PattayaPatrol / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Grand Theft Auto VI is one of the most anticipated entertainment releases ever. Millions of people, young and old, will play it. This guide explains, in plain language, how the game works, why it is so popular, and what it gets wrong about Black men and crime, because those mistakes are not harmless. Someone is making money from them.

What Is GTA, Exactly?

Grand Theft Auto, or GTA, is a video game series made by Rockstar Games and sold by Take-Two Interactive. "Grand theft auto" is the legal term for stealing a car. That tells you a lot about the game.

GTA is an "open-world" game. That means the player gets a whole make-believe city to roam, not a single track to follow. You can drive, walk, listen to the car radio, go shopping, or take on "missions," which are jobs the game gives you, like robbing a bank or chasing down a rival. Most of those missions involve crime.

If you have never played, think of it as a movie where you hold the remote and decide what the main character does next.

There are three simple reasons.

It feels free. In everyday life, most of us follow rules all day long. GTA lets players break every rule with no real consequences. If your character crashes, gets arrested or dies, you press a button and start again.

It rewards you constantly. Steal a car and you get money. Win a shootout and you get points and respect. Game designers call this a "reward loop": do something, get a prize, want to do it again. It is the same trick slot machines and social media use to keep us hooked.

It looks real. Each new GTA is built to look like a real American city. The streets, the music and the way people talk all feel familiar. That realism is a big part of the thrill, and a big part of the problem.

"It's Just Satire": What That Means

Rockstar has long said GTA is satire. Satire is a kind of storytelling that uses jokes and exaggeration to make fun of something in society so people will see how foolish or wrong it is. Think of a cartoon that pokes fun at greedy politicians by drawing them as pigs.

The game does poke fun at greedy companies, silly TV ads and corrupt police. But satire only works if the audience gets the joke. Many players, especially young ones, do not experience GTA as a joke about America. They experience it as a power fantasy, a daydream where you are strong, rich and untouchable. When the joke is missed, what is left is the fun of stealing and shooting.

"But Everybody in GTA Is a Criminal"

Fans of the game often say, "GTA isn't just about Black people." That's true. Over the years, the series has made fun of almost every kind of criminal:

  • *Italian mobsters in GTA III: two Mafia families, the Leones and the Forellis, like something out of The Godfather*.
  • *A white drug lord in Vice City: Tommy Vercetti fights Cuban and Haitian gangs in 1980s Miami, like the movie Scarface*.
  • *An immigrant in GTA IV:* Niko Bellic, a former soldier from Eastern Europe, gets pulled into the Russian mob.
  • *Three very different men in GTA V:* Michael, a retired white bank robber in the suburbs who sees a therapist; Trevor, a wild white drug dealer out in the desert; and crooked government agents based on the FBI and CIA.
  • In every game: drug cartels, dirty cops, greedy tech companies and gangsters of all kinds.

So white characters get stereotypes too. Tommy is the gangster who wants to be king. Michael is the tired mobster in therapy. Trevor is the crazy country outlaw. It can look like the game treats everyone the same: everybody is a crook.

Here's the catch. It isn't the same, for two simple reasons.

1. White crime looks like a movie. Black crime looks like the news. When white characters break the law in GTA, it feels like a Hollywood film: a mob drama, a spy story, a dark comedy. Nobody finishes the game and starts fearing Italian or Eastern European men on the street. But CJ and Franklin are placed in the hood, with gangs and police chases. That is the same picture of Black men people see on the evening news, and the same picture used to justify stopping, arresting and locking up real Black men. For the white characters, crime is make-believe. For the Black characters, it backs up a stereotype real people live with.

2. The other gangsters are the background. Black culture is the selling point. The mobsters and cartels are just villains to beat. What makes GTA feel cool is Black music, slang, style and attitude, from the West Coast rap of San Andreas to the Southern rap that sells GTA VI. Saying "the game makes fun of everybody" lets the company off the hook. It gets to make the most money from Black culture while keeping its Black characters stuck in crime.

3. The trap of "honest" work and the missing Black city.

Whenever people point out that Grand Theft Auto traps Black characters in crime, fans love to argue back: "You don't have to break the law. You can get an honest job!" You can drive a taxi, pick people up in an ambulance, drive a tow truck or move shipping containers down at the docks.

That sounds fair until you look at the math. Driving a cab or running an ambulance in GTA pays about $30 to $60 a fare. But basic body armor costs thousands, and finishing the game takes millions. You would have to drive tens of thousands of cab rides just to afford a decent house. The game deliberately makes honest work boring, slow and dead-ended. The message programmed right into it is simple: playing by the rules is for suckers, and crime is the only way to get ahead.

Worse, this setup treats Black and white characters completely differently. In GTA V, Michael, a white retired bank robber, lives in a mansion, plays tennis, visits an expensive therapist and eventually becomes a Hollywood movie producer. Crime is just a messy phase on his way back to being a respectable, wealthy family man. Franklin, the young Black lead, gets no such chance. He starts the story repossessing cars from poor folks for a crooked dealer and driving a tow truck. Even when Franklin ends up with millions, he does not get there by starting a real business, going to school or leading his community. His big payday comes from killings arranged to rig the stock market. White characters get a shot at redemption and a second act. Black characters simply graduate from street hustler to high-end hitman.

Even when the game lets players buy businesses in GTA Online, honest work is still a lie. You can buy a nightclub, an auto shop, an arcade or an agency. But none of them are real businesses. The auto shop is a chop shop for stolen cars, the nightclub is a cover for a weapons bunker, and the agency is a hub for contract hits. The game insists that every dollar in America is dirty. But while it mocks greedy white executives at the top, it treats Black characters as if they can never build wealth any other way.

The biggest problem with GTA is not just what it shows. It is what it leaves out. The game builds giant digital cities modeled on Los Angeles and Miami, but it erases the Black people who hold those cities together. In hundreds of hours of play, you never meet a Black doctor, a high school teacher, an HBCU professor, a church deacon, a union steward or a neighborhood organizer. White society is mocked from top to bottom: tech billionaires, crooked politicians, corrupt federal agents and strange self-help gurus. But Black life is stripped down to street gangs, weed shops and strip clubs. By erasing real Black institutions, the game tells millions of young players around the world that Black communities have no history, no leaders and no everyday heroes, only criminals and victims.

You can see how glaring this gap is by looking at what everyday gamers did when they got the chance. On fan-run "roleplay" servers like NoPixel, players threw out the usual shootouts and wrote their own rules. Black players chose to become hospital doctors, trauma nurses, 911 dispatchers, defense lawyers, judges and small-business owners. Gamers had to step in and rebuild the real Black city the developers left out. In doing so, they proved that everyday Black life is about work, family and community, and that keeping Black men in a digital jail was always a corporate choice.

Where the Images Come From

From the Hood to the Hard Drive: How a real struggle became a billion-dollar game, in four steps
From the Hood to the Hard Drive: How a real struggle became a billion-dollar game, in four steps
Save infographicOn iPhone: tap, then press and hold the image to save it to Photos.

The game did not invent its picture of Black city life. It borrowed it.

In 1991, director John Singleton released Boyz n the Hood, a film about young Black men growing up in South Central Los Angeles. Singleton grew up there himself. His film showed the violence, but it treated every death as a loss. Its message was a warning: this is killing us, and it has to stop.

Crenshaw Boulevard in South Los Angeles, the real neighborhood that films like Boyz n the Hood portrayed. Photo: Downtowngal / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Crenshaw Boulevard in South Los Angeles, the real neighborhood that films like Boyz n the Hood portrayed. Photo: Downtowngal / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Game makers saw how powerful those images were. In 2004, GTA: San Andreas put players in the shoes of Carl "CJ" Johnson, a young Black man returning to a fictional Los Angeles neighborhood called Grove Street. The look, the music and even the story echo 1990s "hood" films. In 2013, GTA V gave players Franklin Clinton, a young Black man from South Los Santos trying to escape a dead-end life by working with criminals.

Both characters are written with some sympathy. Players like them. But in the game, the only way up for these Black men is crime. What Singleton offered as a warning, the game turns into entertainment. Getting chased by police becomes a fun mission instead of a tragedy.

Early fan talk about Grand Theft Auto VI shows the same narrow choice carried into the newest game. In a widely shared post on X, Jay McGill wrote that the game's couple, Jason and Lucia, can escape Vice City with their son only if they have $2 million, a strong relationship, equal effort and a "professional" criminal status. The post he quoted joked that the only other endings are getting killed or locked up. The game adds family and romance, but the rule has not changed: the only way out is to become a better criminal, and failure means a grave or a cell.

From the Screen to the Street: The "Kia Boys"

Beginning around 2022, videos spread on TikTok and other apps showing teenagers stealing certain Kia and Hyundai cars. Many of those models lacked an anti-theft device and could be started with a USB cable. The thieves called themselves "Kia Boys," and their videos looked a lot like GTA: fast driving, filmed from inside the car, set to music, posted for likes.

A Kia car. Many older Kia and Hyundai models lacked anti-theft devices, which fueled the viral "Kia Boys" theft trend. Photo: Alexander Migl / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
A Kia car. Many older Kia and Hyundai models lacked anti-theft devices, which fueled the viral "Kia Boys" theft trend. Photo: Alexander Migl / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The companies later offered software fixes and paid settlements to owners. But the young people in the videos paid too, with arrests, crashes and, in some cities, deaths. In the game, a crash means restart. On the street, there is no restart.

To be clear, video games do not turn people into criminals. Research has not shown that playing violent games causes violent crime. The issue is different: the game, the movies and the social media feed all repeat the same story about who Black young men are. Repeated often enough, a story starts to feel like truth, to the boys themselves and to the people who police, hire and judge them.

Reality TV and AI: The Same Story, New Screens

Reality TV often works the same way. Producers look for drama, so they cast and edit Black men as loud, dangerous or "hustling," because conflict gets ratings. The shows are called "reality," but much of what you see is shaped in the editing room.

Artificial intelligence, or AI, adds a new layer. AI is software that learns patterns from huge amounts of data. When that data is full of the same images of Black criminality, from games, shows and news, the AI repeats them. Researchers have already found that some AI image tools produce Black faces far more often when asked to picture "a criminal" or "a thief." Old stereotypes get a new, automated life.

What Boyz n the Hood Was Really About

People remember the gunshots in Boyz n the Hood. They forget the father. Furious Styles, played by Laurence Fishburne, spends the film teaching his son Tre to think: about who owns the liquor stores, why there is a gun shop on every corner, what gentrification means, and why a Black man has to take responsibility for his children. Singleton's real hero is not the hustler. It is the man who stays, teaches and refuses the trap.

That is the part the games leave out. In GTA, there are almost no fathers, elders, teachers or organizers. The bigger story of Black manhood, the one about protecting, building and raising the next generation, gets cut. What remains is the gun and the getaway car.

What Our Archive Shows About AI and Black Life

HistorianSpeaks has followed how new technology treats Black people, and the pattern matches what we see in games:

  • Who teaches the machine matters. In [Six Hundred Hours of Black Voices](/blog/howard-google-black-voices-ai-dataset), we looked at Howard University's work with Google to record Black speech so voice AI stops misunderstanding Black speakers. When Black people are missing from the data, the machine gets us wrong.
  • Who pays for the cloud. [Power Without Permission](/blog/data-centers-black-memphis-boxtown) showed how an AI data center landed next to Black Memphis neighborhoods, bringing pollution concerns without community consent.
  • Who gets watched. [Papers, Please, Again](/blog/papers-please-again-ice-black-america) traced how surveillance tools fall hardest on Black Americans. Software trained on stereotypes about Black crime makes that worse.
  • Who built it. Our AI series profiles Black pioneers such as Clarence "Skip" Ellis, Roy Clay and Gladys West, whose work helped make modern computing and GPS possible. Black men have been builders of this technology, not only its targets.

The lesson ties back to the game: the same pictures that sell GTA also feed the machines that decide who looks "suspicious."

Who Profits, and Who Pays

GTA V alone has sold more than 200 million copies and earned billions of dollars. That money goes to the game company and its investors. Black communities whose lives inspired the game's look and sound do not share in that profit.

The business model now runs through Black music, too. In November 2026, Rockstar Games and Atlantic Records released Grand Theft Auto VI: The Album, an official 34-track album built heavily on Black Southern rap, featuring Travis Scott, Cardi B, Playboi Carti, Future and Metro Boomin, Kodak Black, Young Thug, Burna Boy and SZA, with a launch concert in Miami. The game itself carries 22 radio stations, the most in the series. Rockstar is selling this game with Black music and Black culture at the center of its marketing, while, as Jay McGill's breakdown of the endings shows, the story still only lets its heroes escape as professional criminals. The culture is the product; the people remain the punchline. Launch week showed the other side of that bargain: EBONY reported Black gamers taking time off work and hosting midnight streams in celebration, with the soundtrack and an in-game nod to streamer IShowSpeed drawing particular pride.

Meanwhile, the real costs, such as prison records, lost jobs, grief and fear, fall on real people. Black Americans are already imprisoned at far higher rates than white Americans. A culture that makes Black crime look normal, cool or funny makes that unfairness easier to ignore.

What We Can Do

This is not a call to panic or to blame young people for enjoying games. As Lawrence Ware wrote in The Root, playing GTA can feel "like being Marlo from The Wire without having to worry about going to prison" — honest escapism that does not erase the stereotypes. Gaming is also a place of Black creativity: designers, streamers, esports teams and players who just enjoy a well-built world. Car culture has proud Black roots too, from custom car clubs to the mechanics who kept neighborhoods running.

Here are some simple steps for families, teachers and players:

  • Talk about it. Ask young players: Who are the Black characters? What choices does the game give them? Would that be true in real life?
  • Watch the source. Watch Boyz n the Hood together and compare how the film and the game treat the same violence.
  • Question the feed. When a viral video makes crime look fun, ask who is filming, who is profiting and who gets hurt.
  • Support other stories. Look for games, shows and creators that show Black men as builders, thinkers, fathers and friends.

The reset button exists only on the screen. Our young people deserve stories, and futures, that understand the difference.

Further Reading on HistorianSpeaks

Why your support matters

Liked this story? Get one like it in your inbox every week.

HistorianSpeaks is independent and reader-supported. No corporate owners, no paywall on the daily history. Every member keeps stories like this one coming.

Free

Newsletter

The weekly dispatch in your inbox.

Most impact

Founding member

$9.99/month

Price locked for life, founder recognition and full Black Thread magazine access.

Become a founder

Student

$4.99/month

Every Black Thread story in full, with a school (.edu) email.

Join as a student
Share:
Cite this blog:
"What GTA Gets Wrong About Black Men." Historianspeaks, November 21, 2026. https://historianspeaks.org/blog/gta-vi-reality-tv-ai-black-masculinity. "source." theroot.com, , accessed November 21, 2026, https://www.theroot.com/professor-yes-grand-theft-auto-is-racist-but-this-bl-2000136127. "https://www.take2games.com/ir." take2games.com, , accessed November 21, 2026, https://www.take2games.com/ir. "https://www.rockstargames.com/VI." rockstargames.com, , accessed November 21, 2026, https://www.rockstargames.com/VI. "https://www.sentencingproject.org/reports/the-color-of-justice-racial-and-ethnic-disparity-in-state-prisons-the-sentencing-project/." sentencingproject.org, , accessed November 21, 2026, https://www.sentencingproject.org/reports/the-color-of-justice-racial-and-ethnic-disparity-in-state-prisons-the-sentencing-project/. "https://www.apa.org/about/policy/resolution-violent-video-games.pdf." apa.org, , accessed November 21, 2026, https://www.apa.org/about/policy/resolution-violent-video-games.pdf. "https://www.nhtsa.gov/." nhtsa.gov, , accessed November 21, 2026, https://www.nhtsa.gov/. "https://www.complex.com/music/a/dimassanfiorenzo/grand-theft-auto-vi-album-tracklist-features." complex.com, , accessed November 21, 2026, https://www.complex.com/music/a/dimassanfiorenzo/grand-theft-auto-vi-album-tracklist-features.

Ask the Historian

Have a question about this story, or an idea for a future post? Send it here.

Stay Current

Join our mailing list

One dispatch a week: a new essay, a podcast episode, and something from the archive worth a second look.